Ousted Somali Chief Justice and Five Supreme Court Judges File Lawsuit Against President at East African Court of Justice

ARUSHA (WDN)– Somalia’s ousted Supreme Court Chief Justice, Bashe Yusuf Ahmed, together with five other Supreme Court justices, has filed a lawsuit against the Federal Government of Somalia before the East African Court of Justice (EACJ), challenging the removal of the Chief Justice and alleging executive interference in the independence of the country’s judiciary.

The applicants have brought the case against the Federal Republic of Somalia and the State Attorney General. In a notification dated November 18, 2026, the First Instance Division of the East African Court of Justice formally directed the Attorney General of the Federal Government of Somalia to submit a response to the case within 45 days, in accordance with the court’s procedural rules.

The legal action follows President Hassan Sheikh Mohamud’s decision on November 4, 2026, to remove Chief Justice Bashe Yusuf Ahmed from office and reinstate his predecessor, Ibrahim Idle Suleiman. The President’s decision triggered a major legal dispute over the constitutional authority of the executive branch to remove the head of the country’s highest judicial institution and raised broader questions about the separation of powers and judicial independence in Somalia.

The controversy deepened when Somalia’s Supreme Court subsequently declared the President’s decision to remove Bashe null and void, arguing that the dismissal violated constitutional procedures and that the President lacked the unilateral authority to remove the Chief Justice. The court further accused the President of attempting to interfere with ongoing constitutional proceedings before the Supreme Court, including a politically sensitive case challenging constitutional amendments and the mandates of federal government institutions.

As Isha Qarsoon observed in an earlier WardheerNews analysis of the controversy surrounding the removal of Chief Justice Bashe Yusuf Ahmed: “A state becomes constitutional when its institutions can exercise their authority without the permission of those they are meant to restrain.”

The dispute has since evolved into a broader constitutional confrontation between the executive and judicial branches, with significant implications for the rule of law, institutional accountability and the independence of Somalia’s judiciary. By bringing the matter before the East African Court of Justice, Bashe and the five other justices have extended the legal challenge beyond Somalia’s domestic judicial system, placing the country’s judicial crisis before a regional court.

The latest legal action before the East African Court of Justice adds a new dimension to the constitutional dispute and underscores the continuing debate over judicial independence and the separation of powers in Somalia.

The proceedings represent another significant test of Somalia’s constitutional institutions and their ability to operate independently, uphold the rule of law and resolve disputes over the exercise of state authority through established legal mechanisms.

Source: WardheerNews

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.