By Towfik Elmi

As the newly emerging Northeastern State of Somalia seeks to address clan-based grievances and decades of neglect and marginalization, it faces significant challenges in establishing effective governance. A critical priority must be the formation of a Civil Service Recruitment Center (CSRC) mandated with operationalizing merit-based recruitment process and vetting of public officials. The core of this mandate must be a comprehensive regulation for the civil service hiring process. It is to include establishing job descriptions for all authorized/funded positions and evaluation criteria for ranking of applicants as a basis for selection. The regulation must be applicable to all non-elective positions funded under public payroll. 

The CRSC would serve as a foundational pillar in building a competent civil service, as seen in similar initiatives in countries such as Rwanda and Ghana, where merit-based recruitment has significantly improved public administration. In this article, I will discuss and provide a high-level guidance on overcoming two important obstacles: the lack of skilled personnel and the challenge of political interference in order to build viable and functioning state institutions.

A Civil Service Center

The CSRC would be tasked with creating standardized vetting procedures for high-level appointments, particularly the post of Secretary General (Director General) for each ministry. The Director General represents the highest-ranking civil servant within a ministry or state agency, serving as the administrative backbone while overseeing policy implementation. This critical post must be insulated from clan-based pressures. It requires a rigorous selection process grounded in competence, leadership capability, and public ethics. This selection process should culminate in in a recommendation by a clan-diverse team of at least three, and final selection by the agency head from a recommended list.

To fulfill this mandate, the CSRC shall establish an Independent Review Committee (IRC) composed of senior civil servants and legal experts. The IRC will conduct interviews, review qualifications, and ensure that all candidates for Director General position meet the established criteria, such as:

1) Academic and professional qualifications.
2) Demonstrated experience in public administration or relevant private sector leadership.
3) Ethical conduct and track record of transparency.  
4) Capacity to manage resources, personnel, and interagency coordination.

The selection process must include background checks, interviews, written evaluations, and conflict-of-interest disclosures. Candidates’ affiliations or clan lineage must not override objective assessment, thereby affirming the principle of meritocracy as an essential first-step for state-building.

Advisory Role in Civil Service Development

Beyond its recruitment role, the Center will function in an advisory capacity to the Office of the Director General across all ministries. This process entails:

1) Supporting ministries in retaining qualified personnel through capacity-building programs, performance evaluation mechanisms, and incentive structures. 
2) Organizing professional training workshops on leadership, public financial management, procurement law, and administrative ethics.
3) Developing guidelines and policy standardization for ministry-level HR departments, ensuring harmonization of hiring practices and service conditions across government.
4) Such advisory functions are critical for preventing politicization and ensuring that civil servants are equipped to carry out their responsibilities efficiently and ethically (World Bank, 2019).

Parliamentary Candidate Vetting

The selection of Members of Parliament (MPs) also requires reform to ensure that the legislative branch reflects competence, not just clan representation. While clan inclusion is constitutionally and culturally significant in Somalia, the criteria for parliamentary selection/election must emphasize capacity, education, and integrity. The minimum eligibility should include:

1) A secondary school diploma (equivalent to Grade 12) to ensure basic literacy and critical thinking skills.
2) Demonstrated ability to read and interpret laws, contracts, and procedural texts.
3) A record of public or private sector work experience, such as successful business leadership, community development initiatives, project management, or public service.
4) A commitment to the principles of constitutionalism, rule of law, and anti-corruption.

By enforcing such standards, MPs will be better positioned to perform oversight functions, draft legislation, and engage in meaningful deliberation.

Reducing Clan-Based Clientelism or Nepotism

The establishment of the CSRC is essential in disrupting and arresting the entrenched clientelist logic and nepotism that often drive appointments in fragile states. In the Somali context, appointments based solely on clan identity, cronyism, or nepotism have historically undermined institutional integrity and the delivery of basic services. As described in the literature, prioritizing technical competence (such as expertise in relevant fields), experience, and integrity over identity politics is fundamental for planting the seeds of an effective and sound administration and gaining the trust of the citizens (Brinkerhoff, 2007; Rotberg, 2004).

While the CSRC should respect clan-based equity and balance among stakeholders, especially in the sensitive political ecosystem of the emerging state, it must recast clan identity as one component rather than the sole determinant of public appointments. This vetting system requires strong backing of the leadership, transparency in decision-making, and public reporting of outcomes.

Conclusion

The creation of a civil service recruitment center for the Northeastern State of Somalia is not merely a bureaucratic endeavor, but a strategic investment in governance reform, accountability, peacebuilding, and institutional legitimacy. By ensuring that only competent individuals are appointed, the state not only boosts operational capacity but also builds public trust and creates a robust defense against corrupt practices. Additionally, ensuring that MPs meet baseline educational and ethical standards will empower the legislative arm of the government to fulfill its constitutional duties and hold the executive branch accountable.

In sum, this center will serve as a catalyst for building a professional civil service and meritocratic political elite, two pillars that are indispensable for sustainable governance in Somalia.

Towfik Elmi
Email:  towfik.elmi@gmail.com
——————
References

Brinkerhoff, D. W. (2007). Governance in Post-Conflict Societies: Rebuilding Fragile States.  Routledge.
Rotberg, R. I. (2004). When States Fail: Causes and Consequences. JSTOR.
World Bank. (2019). Pathways for building a capable public service in post-conflict countries. World Bank Group. Retrieved from https://www.worldbank.org/en/news/feature/2019/02/12/pathways-for-building-a-capable-public-service-in-post-conflict-countries